5 Best Muffler Shops in New York (2026)

What people praise

• Reviewers describe catalytic converter and exhaust work completed at prices well below competing quotes
• Staff are repeatedly called knowledgeable, showing customers the actual problem rather than just describing it
• Named staff like Gene and Tony come up across multiple reviews for informal, straightforward service

Worth knowing

• One reviewer described a large gap between an initial exhaust quote and the final bill
• As a chain location, pricing on bigger jobs can run higher than independent shops

What people praise

• The only shop on this page with a perfect five-star average across hundreds of reviews
• Reviewers specifically praise Carlos's welding quality and attention to detail on custom jobs
• Walk-ins without an appointment are handled promptly, according to multiple reviewers

Worth knowing

• One reviewer noted pricing on premium, high-end work runs steeper, though called it worth it for the quality

What people praise

• Reviewers describe fast turnaround on urgent repairs, including a dangling exhaust fixed same-day
• Named staff Dan, Phil, and Zack come up repeatedly for honest, no-surprise pricing
• One customer switched to this shop for all future inspections despite driving in from another borough

Worth knowing

• No website, so hours and services should be confirmed by phone

What people praise

• Reviewers describe detailed custom exhaust work, including staggered tips and resonator deletes on newer models
• One reviewer who initially received a quote between $600 and $1,250 elsewhere had the same job done for far less here after pushing back
• Jose is named directly and repeatedly as direct, patient, and fairly priced

Worth knowing

• Custom and performance work naturally varies more in price than a standard muffler swap

What people praise

• Reviewers consistently describe pricing well below competing quotes from both independent shops and chains
• One customer had a quoted $380 pipe replacement done for $160 in under 30 minutes
• The shop's connection to owner Lenny's separate art collection gets repeat mentions as a memorable extra

Worth knowing

• One reviewer described a dispute over an unapproved repair charge and vehicle left with a dead battery afterward
• A separate reviewer noted the mufflers used aren't name-brand, expecting three to five years of life rather than longer