Best in Hood
Menu
CitiesGuidesSubmit your businessReviews processAboutContact

5 Best Tire Shops in New York (2026)

Independently ranked by our review of ratings, reviews and reputation · How we chose

Talise Sterling
By Talise Sterling, Goods and Shopping · ✓ Data verified July 2026 · 7 min read

A flat tire in New York usually means finding the nearest shop fast, and the tire shops on this page have logged over 2,300 reviews between them, with ratings from 4.1 to 4.7. That spread of nearly half a star matters more than it sounds, because the lower-rated shops here get called out for the exact same thing in review after review: not quoting a price until you're standing in front of them.

Short answer: Marcy Tires and Rush Auto Tire Shop are tied at the top with a 4.7 rating, Marcy carrying 303 reviews and Rush 291. Rush stands out for a specific, repeated theme in its reviews: no upselling, no price games, and a promotion pairing four new tires with a free alignment. If pricing transparency matters to you, read the reviews on Carlos' Flat Fixed and Las Rodriguez 24hr Tire Shop first.
Jump to a business

New York Tire Shops, Rated and Compared

# Business Rating Reviews Best for
1 Marcy Tires 4.7 ★ 303 Fast repairs, tied top rating View ›
2 Rush Auto Tire Shop 4.7 ★ 291 Full-service repair, not just tires View ›
3 Carlos’ Flat Fixed 4.1 ★ 657 Central Manhattan location View ›
4 Las Rodriguez 24hr Tire shop 4.3 ★ 485 24-hour availability View ›
5 Jireh Tire 4.1 ★ 578 Fleet and repeat commercial customers View ›
5 Best Tire Shops in New York (2026)

Which shop fits your situation

Marcy Tires logo
#1 Overall🕑 Open 6 days/wk

Marcy Tires

4.7303 Google reviews

Marcy Tires operates out of Park Avenue in Brooklyn, handling both passenger and truck tires, new and used. Reviewers describe the shop as fast, straightforward, and specifically good value for truck tires. It's a walk-up operation with no website, running purely on Google reviews and repeat business.

What people praise

  • Repair turnaround as fast as 10-20 minutes reported by multiple reviewers
  • Praised specifically for truck tire pricing and selection
  • One customer reported using the shop for three years running
Reputation scorecardrank in New York
Rating4.7 / 5
Review volume303 · 71th
Confidencehigh
Recency6 weeks ago
Info completenessphone · hours
Rating breakdown89% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: Ties for the top rating on this page with strong repeat-customer signal in the reviews. A solid default if speed matters and you're near Brooklyn.

+1718-486-9890 Directions

528 Park Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205

Rush Auto Tire Shop logo
#2🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

Rush Auto Tire Shop

4.7291 Google reviews

Rush Auto Tire Shop, based on Atlantic Avenue in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn, covers tires, brakes, wheel alignments, oil changes, and general auto repair with same-day service and no appointment needed. The shop runs a promotion pairing four new tires with a free wheel alignment, and reviewers consistently describe honest, no-upsell service.

What people praise

  • Multiple reviewers specifically praise the shop for not upselling or pressuring customers
  • Several reviews note the shop treats customers consistently regardless of who's asking
  • Named technicians (Roman, Ramon, Chucky, Diego) repeatedly credited for honest diagnosis
Reputation scorecardrank in New York
Rating4.7 / 5
Review volume291 · 66th
Confidencehigh
Recency3 months ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown84% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: Ties for the top rating and offers the widest service menu of any shop on this page, so it's a strong pick if you want tires and other repairs handled in one visit.

Website Book now+1347-533-8054 Directions

1263 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216

Carlos’ Flat Fixed logo
#3🕑 Open 7 days

Carlos’ Flat Fixed

4.1657 Google reviews

Carlos' Flat Fixed sits on West 45th Street in Manhattan, a walk-up tire repair shop with no listed website, unclaimed on Google. It has the highest review volume of any shop on this page at 657 reviews, with a 4.1 rating, the lowest on this page.

What people praise

  • Fast turnaround reported for run-flat and standard repairs, including a same-visit fix on a BMW
  • One long-time customer described consistent quality and professionalism over many years

Worth knowing

  • Multiple detailed reviews describe the price for a tire plug varying by day or by customer, with no price given over the phone
  • One reviewer reported being charged double the usual rate with no explanation
Reputation scorecardrank in New York
Rating4.1 / 5
Review volume657 · 97th
Confidencehigh
Recency2 months ago
Info completenessphone · hours
Rating breakdown72% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: The location is convenient for Midtown Manhattan, and plenty of reviewers had a fine experience, but the pricing complaints here are specific and repeated enough to ask for a firm price before any work starts.

+1212-765-1280 Directions

503 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036

Las Rodriguez 24hr Tire shop logo
#4🕑 Open 7 days

Las Rodriguez 24hr Tire shop

4.3485 Google reviews

Las Rodriguez 24hr Tire Shop operates around the clock from 39th Street in Brooklyn, an unclaimed Google listing with 485 reviews and a 4.3 rating. As the name suggests, its main draw is availability outside normal business hours for flat tires and quick repairs.

What people praise

  • Fast service repeatedly described, including a five-minute turnaround for a tire change
  • Multiple reviewers specifically call the pricing insanely good or great
  • 24-hour availability is a real differentiator for late-night or early-morning flats

Worth knowing

  • One detailed review describes a dismissive, confrontational experience with a staff member over a tire diagnosis and receipt
Reputation scorecardrank in New York
Rating4.3 / 5
Review volume485 · 87th
Confidencehigh
Recency4 months ago
Info completenessphone · hours
Rating breakdown74% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: The round-the-clock hours make this the shop to know about for a flat at an inconvenient time. Most reviews are positive on speed and price, though one detailed account of a rude interaction is worth being aware of.

+1718-499-9531 Directions

262 39th St, Brooklyn, NY 11232

Jireh Tire logo
#5🕑 Open 7 days

Jireh Tire

4.1578 Google reviews

Jireh Tire, located on East 116th Street in Harlem, handles new and used tires plus wheel sales, with 578 reviews and a 4.1 rating. One recent review notes the original building was condemned and torn down, suggesting the shop may be relocating, so confirm its current address before visiting.

What people praise

  • Reviewers describe fast service, including two flats fixed in under 20 minutes
  • One commercial customer praised the shop for reliably servicing multiple work vans
  • Tire pressure checked and topped off as a courtesy alongside repairs, per multiple reviewers

Worth knowing

  • A recent review indicates the original building has been demolished; confirm the current operating location before visiting
  • One reviewer noted a lack of detail work on a tire fix, though it held up fine
Reputation scorecardrank in New York
Rating4.1 / 5
Review volume578 · 92th
Confidencehigh
Recency3 weeks ago
Info completenessphone · hours
Rating breakdown64% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: Good reviews on speed and fair pricing, but the demolition note in a recent review is a real flag. Call ahead to confirm the shop's current address before making the trip to Harlem.

+1212-665-6050 Directions

2 E 116th St, New York, NY 10029

6

Your business here

Get listed on this page, in front of local customers already searching for you.

Claim this spot ›

How we score these shops

Rating is the live average from Google reviews. Review volume shows how many customers actually left feedback, which we weigh against the rating rather than treating stars alone as the answer. Confidence combines both, so a 4.1 with hundreds of reviews scores differently than a 4.7 with a smaller base. Recency checks how current the feedback is. No shop can pay to change any of these numbers.

What does a tire repair or replacement cost in New York? (2026)

Reviewers across these shops mention actual prices they paid, which gives a rough sense of the range for a basic flat repair in the city. New tire prices vary too widely by size and brand to quote generally, so ask for a specific quote on your tire size.

JobTypical price
Flat tire plug/repair (Marcy Tires, reviewer-reported)Around $28
Flat tire plug/repair (Carlos’ Flat Fixed, reviewer-reported, standard rate)Around $15
Flat tire plug/repair (Carlos’ Flat Fixed, reviewer-reported, variable rate)Up to $30

Prices compiled July 2026 from prices customers reported paying in their Google reviews at Marcy Tires and Carlos’ Flat Fixed. Ask for a firm price before work begins, since reviews indicate quotes can vary.

Covering Brooklyn, Manhattan, and Harlem

These shops span Brooklyn (Park Avenue, Atlantic Avenue, 39th Street), Midtown Manhattan, and Harlem, so most New Yorkers have at least one option within a short drive. If you’re searching for tire shops near me anywhere across the boroughs covered here, one of them should be close by.

What to ask before you visit a tire shop

  • Can you give me a firm price over the phone before I come in?
  • Do you charge differently for a plug repair versus a full tire replacement?
  • Is a wheel alignment included with a new tire purchase, or is it extra?
  • Do you carry my tire size in stock, or will I need to wait for an order?
  • Do you accept walk-ins, or do I need an appointment?
  • Is there a warranty on the repair or the new tire?

Frequently asked questions

Are these rankings paid?

No. Rankings come from public Google data. A business can pay to be a Featured Partner (badge and top placement), but that never changes another business’s score or position.

How did you choose these tire shops?

We pulled every tire shop in New York with a meaningful public Google presence, then ranked by a mix of rating, review volume, and how current the feedback is.

How often is this updated?

This page was last verified in July 2026 using live Google review data, and we refresh it periodically as ratings and review counts change.

Which shop is open 24 hours?

Las Rodriguez 24hr Tire Shop advertises round-the-clock availability, useful for a flat outside normal business hours.

Why do some reviews mention price disputes?

A few shops on this page have reviews describing prices that weren’t quoted upfront. Asking for a firm price before work starts avoids most of these situations.

Do any of these shops handle more than tires?

Rush Auto Tire Shop offers the widest menu, including brakes, alignments, and oil changes alongside tire service.

The bottom line

Marcy Tires and Rush Auto Tire Shop are the safest defaults on this page, tied at the top rating with reviewers specifically praising honest pricing. Whichever shop you call, ask for a firm price before the work starts, since that’s the one issue that separates the top-rated shops from the rest of this list.

Own one of these businesses, or want to be here?

Claim your spot on this page: Basic listing $50 or Premium $100 for the top spot, held a full year. Both include a permanent link to your site.

Get listed See pricing