5 Best Property Management Companies in New York (2026)

R.E.M. Residential is a Manhattan property management company on West 36th Street handling residential buildings across New York City, with a particular reputation for careful maintenance of older, pre-war apartments. The company balances routine repairs with respect for original architectural details, and reviewers specifically mention full kitchen remodels executed without compromising a building's historic character. Long-term tenants describe more than a decade of consistently reliable service from the same management team.

XL Real Property Management is a Fifth Avenue-based firm managing luxury individual apartments, rental buildings up to 50 units, and pied-à-terre or owner-occupied properties across Manhattan and Brooklyn. The company has operated since 2012 and reviewers repeatedly describe smooth coordination across vendor and contractor relationships, not just tenant-facing service. Multiple reviewers cite over a decade of working with the same company as it scaled from a startup into an established team.

Daisy is a modern property management company for NYC and NJ condos, co-ops, and HOAs, built around its own proprietary building operating system for maintenance, package management, and resident services. The company took over management of a 414-unit building nine months before its most recent reviews, and reviewers describe a smooth transition despite the size and complexity of the property. The tech-forward approach is paired with real, named staff rather than purely automated communication.

New York Living Solutions is a real estate team operating under Keller Williams NYC, based on John Street in the Financial District, handling apartment rentals, sales, and commercial real estate across the city. While broader than a pure property management firm, the team's reviews focus heavily on agents guiding renters and landlords through the leasing process, particularly first-time renters navigating New York's market independently. Individual agents are named repeatedly for patience and clear communication throughout.

Sky Management is a Manhattan property management and development company based on East 54th Street, managing rental buildings and apartments across the city. Reviewers describe an organized, professional leasing process, including a detailed tenant portal and a helpful hints document provided at lease signing. Building managers are named individually and praised for consistent responsiveness to both building-wide and tenant-specific concerns.