The Baxter Inn
The Baxter Inn is an underground whisky bar in the CBD, tucked down an unmarked staircase off Clarence Street, with one of the largest whisky collections in the city behind the bar. It's walk-in only, no reservations, and the space leans into a moody, low-lit speakeasy feel with a rotating cocktail list. The bar is part of the Swillhouse group, which also runs several other well-known Sydney venues.
What people praise
- Reviewers repeatedly call out the unique, hidden-away atmosphere
- Free pretzels mentioned in multiple reviews as a signature touch
- Staff praised for genuine hospitality even on the busiest nights
Worth knowing
- No bookings, so expect a wait or crowd on weekend nights
- Drinks run on the pricier side for the neighborhood
Our take: The highest review volume on this page by a wide margin, and the sentiment holds up at nearly 3,150 five-star reviews. The safest first stop if you only try one place on this list.


