First State Auctions
First State Auctions is a luxury auction house on York Street specialising in fine jewellery, Swiss watches, and designer bags, running since 1995 with an in-house authentication lab staffed by qualified gemmologists and horologists. The business runs weekly online catalogue auctions rather than in-room sales, and reviewers describe a straightforward bidding process backed by staff who help narrow down options rather than just processing a purchase. A 20% buyer's premium applies on top of the hammer price, standard for this category of auction house.
What people praise
- In-house gemmologist and horologist authentication cited as a reason for buyer confidence
- Staff helped narrow a wide catalogue down to a shortlist for a specific request
- Dispatch team praised specifically for careful packaging and paperwork
- Repeat buyers describe consistently accurate photos and descriptions
Worth knowing
- One delivery arrived in damaged outer packaging, though the item inside was undamaged
Our take: First State Auctions posts the strongest rating on this list among the pure luxury specialists, 4.8 across 340 reviews, which explains why it ranks first ahead of the larger general auction houses below.


