Best in Hood
Menu
CitiesGuidesSubmit your businessReviews processAboutContact

5 Best Propane Suppliers in New York (2026)

Independently ranked by our review of ratings, reviews and reputation · How we chose

Brad Smith
By Brad Smith, Home Services Expert · ✓ Data verified July 2026 · 7 min read

Your grill tank runs dry an hour before guests arrive and suddenly every gas station sign matters. Propane suppliers in New York cover a wide mix, dedicated fuel dealers, grill retailers, convenience stores with a cage out back, and on this page alone they've pulled 873 reviews between them, with ratings running 4.3 up to 4.9. Propane LP Gas at Sunoco Station tops the list at 4.9 stars on 187 reviews, but every name here clears 97, so none of the five is a stranger to its customers.

Short answer: Propane LP Gas at Sunoco Station in Mineola leads with 4.9 stars across 187 reviews. Rahway Propane, a veteran-owned refill station open since 1980, also holds 4.9, and reviewers there specifically note it fills tanks to a true full 20 lbs rather than the lighter fill common at exchange cages. Two businesses on this list, a full-service gas station and a hardware store, don't have clear evidence in their reviews of actually offering propane.
Jump to a business

Propane suppliers near New York, side by side

# Business Rating Reviews Best for
1 Propane LP Gas at Sunoco Station 4.9 ★ 187 Convenience-store propane fills View ›
2 Modern Propane 4.6 ★ 222 Grill retailer with propane delivery View ›
3 CONOCO 24-Hr. Full-Service 4.3 ★ 242 Full-service vehicle fuel (propane not confirmed) View ›
4 Rahway Propane 4.9 ★ 97 True full-tank refills, veteran-owned View ›
5 Fulton Supply & Hardware 4.5 ★ 125 General hardware store (not a propane specialist) View ›
5 Best Propane Suppliers in New York (2026)

Our picks, reviewed one by one

Propane LP Gas at Sunoco Station logo
#1 Overall🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

Propane LP Gas at Sunoco Station

4.9187 Google reviews

Propane LP Gas at Sunoco Station is a Mineola convenience store and gas station that fills propane tanks alongside its regular fuel and shop business, run day to day with Tony handling much of the customer follow-up. It's a hybrid setup: gas pumps and a small shop out front, with propane fills available during posted hours rather than the full-service delivery model some dedicated suppliers offer.

What people praise

  • Reviewers describe fast, no-wait service compared to big-box stores
  • Owner (Tony) personally responds to complaints and has corrected pricing mistakes when flagged
  • Convenient one-stop location if you're already filling up on gas

Worth knowing

  • A few reviews describe pump mix-ups or unclear signage on pricing, worth double-checking the current rate before you pay
  • Propane hours are more limited than 24-hour gas sales, one reviewer was turned away after 6pm
Reputation scorecardrank in New York
Rating4.9 / 5
Review volume187 · 84th
Confidencemoderate
Recency2 years ago
Info completenessphone · hours
Rating breakdown96% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: It ranks first on a strong 4.9 average and the deepest recent review activity of the propane-specific businesses on this list. Good for a quick, convenient fill if you're passing through during daytime hours.

+1516-746-6260 Directions

2 Jericho Tpke, Mineola, NY 11501

Modern Propane logo
#2🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

Modern Propane

4.6222 Google reviews

Modern Propane is a Lodi, New Jersey grill and propane retailer with showrooms in Lodi and Toms River, selling Weber, Napoleon, and Broil King grills alongside propane tank sales, refills, and both residential and commercial delivery. It's the most retail-oriented business on this list, built around grills first with propane as a core add-on service rather than the only thing it does.

What people praise

  • Delivery service specifically praised, including scheduled drop-off with instructions on where to leave the tank
  • Staff (Doug, Bobby) named repeatedly for helpful, unpushy advice on grill and tank selection
  • Pricing described by one reviewer as beating Walmart and Home Depot on propane fills

Worth knowing

  • One detailed review describes a delivered tank that later developed a leak; the company removed and replaced it, and the reviewer called the resolution fair, but it's worth inspecting a delivered tank on arrival
  • First-time delivery customers should confirm which day of the week their area is served, since it isn't daily
Reputation scorecardrank in New York
Rating4.6 / 5
Review volume222 · 91th
Confidencemoderate
Recency4 weeks ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown86% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: It ranks second on a 4.6 average across 222 reviews. If you're buying or servicing a grill anyway, doing propane through the same retailer is convenient, and the delivery option is a genuine differentiator from a walk-up station.

Website+1973-778-0812 Directions

199 US-46, Lodi, NJ 07644

CONOCO 24-Hr. Full-Service logo
#3🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

CONOCO 24-Hr. Full-Service

4.3242 Google reviews

CONOCO 24-Hr. Full-Service in Williamsburg, Brooklyn is a staffed, full-service gas station offering vehicle fuel, oil changes, battery replacement, and tire service. Worth flagging clearly: none of its reviews or listed categories mention propane specifically, so while it appears in local search for the category, we found no direct evidence it fills propane tanks the way the other businesses on this list do.

What people praise

  • Staff pump your gas for you, a genuine convenience reviewers call out in bad weather
  • 24-hour full-service is rare in the area
  • Reviewers describe the crew as friendly and quick for basic vehicle service

Worth knowing

  • No review or listed service directly confirms propane tank refills, call ahead before making a trip specifically for that
  • Its Google listing categories focus on vehicle fuel, not propane supply
Reputation scorecardrank in New York
Rating4.3 / 5
Review volume242 · 97th
Confidencemoderate
Recency5 months ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown63% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: It ranks third on review volume and rating among the field, but based on what's actually documented, this is a strong full-service gas station rather than a confirmed propane specialist. Call first if propane is the only reason you're going.

Website+1718-384-4880 Directions

451 Lorimer St, Brooklyn, NY 11206

Rahway Propane logo
#4🕑 Open 7 days

Rahway Propane

4.997 Google reviews

Rahway Propane is a veteran-operated, family-owned propane filling station in Rahway, New Jersey, open since 1980 and serving grills, RVs, food trucks, and commercial accounts. It's a fill-while-you-wait station rather than an exchange service, and the business is explicit that this means a genuinely full tank rather than the roughly 15 lb fill common at cage exchanges.

What people praise

  • True full-tank fills specifically called out by the business and confirmed by reviewers comparing it to exchange cages
  • Open 4am to 9pm, seven days a week including holidays, unusually long hours for this kind of service
  • Personal, friendly service repeatedly mentioned, including a staff member lending a customer an adapter rather than selling one

Worth knowing

  • One reviewer notes it runs a bit pricier than big-box exchange options, though still called worth it for the fill quality
Reputation scorecardrank in New York
Rating4.9 / 5
Review volume97 · 72th
Confidencemoderate
Recency5 weeks ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown93% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: It ranks fourth on a 4.9 average, tied with the top spot, but on a smaller review base (97). If getting a genuinely full tank matters more to you than convenience, this is our top pick on the list.

Website+1732-259-0222 Directions

27 W Hazelwood Ave, Rahway, NJ 07065

Fulton Supply & Hardware logo
#5🕑 Open 7 days

Fulton Supply & Hardware

4.5125 Google reviews

Fulton Supply & Hardware is a Lower Manhattan hardware store offering key duplication, locksmithing, electrical and plumbing supplies, paint, and tool rental. Worth flagging directly: neither its listed service categories nor any of its reviews mention propane, so while it appears in search for the category, it reads as a neighbourhood hardware store rather than a propane supplier.

What people praise

  • Genuinely strong, well-reviewed neighbourhood hardware store for key cutting and general supplies
  • Staff repeatedly praised for going out of their way to help track down hard-to-find items

Worth knowing

  • No evidence in its listing or reviews that it sells or refills propane, this looks like a mismatch for this specific search
Reputation scorecardrank in New York
Rating4.5 / 5
Review volume125 · 78th
Confidencemoderate
Recency5 weeks ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown81% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: It ranks fifth mainly on a solid general rating, but we found nothing to support it as a propane source specifically. If you landed here searching for propane, we'd skip this one and call ahead to confirm before making a trip.

Website+1212-587-4088 Directions

74 Fulton St, New York, NY 10038

6

Your business here

Get listed on this page, in front of local customers already searching for you.

Claim this spot ›

How we score propane suppliers

Rating is the live Google average pulled directly from each business’s profile. Review volume measures how many customers actually left a rating, weighed against the average, since a perfect score on a small sample carries less confidence than one built on hundreds. No business can pay to change these numbers, and where a listing showed up for this category without clear evidence it actually offers the service, we said so rather than writing around it.

What propane costs near New York

None of the five businesses here publish a fixed, current price list, and the cost of a refill depends heavily on tank size, whether it’s a true fill or an exchange, and local competition, so we’re not going to invent a number. What consistently comes up across reviewers’ own accounts: dedicated fill stations that top off your existing tank tend to give you more usable propane per visit than swap-and-exchange cages at big-box stores, even when the sticker price looks similar.

Propane suppliers near New York

This list spans Mineola on Long Island, Lodi and Rahway in New Jersey, and Williamsburg and Lower Manhattan within the city itself. If you’re searching for propane near me, a dedicated fill station like Rahway Propane is usually worth a slightly longer drive over a closer but unconfirmed option.

What to ask before you fill up

  • Is this a true fill-to-capacity refill, or a lighter cage exchange?
  • What are your current propane hours, separate from your general opening hours?
  • Do you deliver, and is there a minimum order or delivery fee?
  • Do you serve larger tanks (RV, commercial) or just standard 20 lb grill tanks?
  • Is same-day service available, or do I need to schedule ahead?

Frequently asked questions

Are these rankings paid?

No. Rankings come from public Google data. A business can pay to be a Featured Partner (badge plus top placement), but that never changes another business’s score or position.

How did you choose these five?

We pulled the businesses that appear for this search near New York, then ranked by a blend of star rating, review volume, and how recently people are still leaving reviews. Where a listing lacked clear evidence it actually offers propane, we flagged that directly instead of assuming.

How often is this page updated?

We refreshed this ranking in July 2026 using live Google data. Ratings and review counts shift over time, so treat the numbers here as a snapshot rather than fixed.

Why do a gas station and a hardware store show up on a propane list?

Google’s local categories aren’t always precise, and both businesses appeared in search results for propane suppliers near New York without clear evidence in their reviews or listings that they actually offer the service. We included them for completeness but were upfront about the gap.

The bottom line

For a straightforward, well-reviewed fill, Propane LP Gas at Sunoco Station is the safe default. If getting a genuinely full tank rather than a lighter exchange matters more to you, Rahway Propane’s fill-while-you-wait model is worth the drive, and its reviewers back that claim up directly.

Own one of these businesses, or want to be here?

Claim your spot on this page: Basic listing $50, Premium $100 with a dofollow link to your site.

Get listed See pricing