5 Best Car Insurance in New York (2026)

Meilee Fu is a State Farm insurance agent operating out of Chinatown in lower Manhattan, offering auto, home, life, business, and several specialty lines including pet and boat insurance, and covering New York City, Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, and Long Island. Fu has run the agency for more than 20 years, and staff member Suzy Chow comes up repeatedly in reviews as a day-to-day point of contact. The agency leans into bundling policies, several long-time clients describe pairing auto, homeowner, and life coverage under one roof.

Robert Springer works as an insurance agent through Comparion Insurance, a brokerage based in the Financial District that shops coverage across multiple carriers rather than selling a single company's policies. He handles auto, home, life, motorcycle, and renter's insurance, and reviewers frequently mention colleague Raquel Dalessio alongside him as part of the same team. Because Comparion compares products from several insurers, reviewers describe being walked through multiple options rather than handed one quote.

Jeff Waddle Ins Agency is a State Farm agency on West 8th Street offering auto, home, health, and life insurance, with staff member Michelene Colette named in nearly every review as the primary contact for claims and policy changes. Clients describe using the agency for cars, motorcycles, and rental coverage, often across several years with the same team.

Silverline Insurance is an independent broker based on Greenwich Street in the Financial District, handling home, auto, and commercial vehicle policies by comparing options across multiple carriers rather than representing a single insurer. Agent Jessica is named in nearly every review as the point of contact, credited with walking first-time home buyers through coverage details most agents skip.

Cheukping Shiu is an insurance agent working through Comparion Insurance out of the same Liberty Street office as Robert Springer, handling auto, home, life, motorcycle, and renter's insurance by comparing multiple carriers rather than one brand. Reviewers describe returning to Shiu after a gap in coverage, including one client who had gone three years without auto insurance and needed a policy set up quickly after buying a new vehicle. Several report multi-year relationships spanning both vehicle and home insurance needs.