
Wooly's Bagels Arab Street
Wooly's Bagels Arab Street is a Muslim-owned bagel shop on Arab St known for chewy, hand-made bagels with creative and often limited-edition fillings, including a spiced chicken thigh bagel called the Hot Mess and rotating specials like a birria beef bagel. It runs primarily as an Instagram-driven counter with a small, cosy dine-in space. It holds the highest rating of any bagel shop on this page.
What people praise
- Highest rating on the list at 4.8
- Reviewers repeatedly praise the Hot Mess and other spiced, meat-heavy fillings
- Chewy, well-textured bagels called out across multiple reviews
- Cosy, small-space atmosphere suited to casual catch-ups
Worth knowing
- Some reviewers feel the meat portion could be more generous for the price
- Small space means limited seating for larger groups
Our take: The top-rated bagel shop on this page, built on creative, well-executed fillings rather than a classic New York approach. A strong pick if you want something more adventurous than a plain lox bagel.



