Skip to content
Best in Hood
Menu
Categories Cities Guides How we rank
Get listed

5 Best Jewelry Stores in Buffalo (2026)

Ranked by real Google ratings and review volume · How we chose

Talise Sterling
By Talise Sterling, Goods and Shopping · ✓ Updated · 8 min read

We compared 20 jewelry stores in Buffalo on Google Maps · 5 listed · How we rank

An engagement ring, or a repair on a family heirloom, is not a purchase you want to second-guess. The jewelry stores in Buffalo on this page hold more than 4,100 Google reviews between them and none is rated below 4.9, so the real choice is what each does best: custom design, antique and estate pieces, repairs, watches or gold buying.

Short answer: Ben Garelick Jewelers has the largest review base, 5.0 stars from more than 1,300 reviews, with a focus on engagement rings and custom design. Brian Michael's Jewelers also holds a 5.0 across more than 790 reviews, and Aurum Jewelers (4.9) is the one to look at for antique and estate pieces. No prices are published here, so ask for written quotes on custom work and repairs.
Jump to a business

Rings, Repairs and Antique Pieces: Who Does What

# Business Rating Reviews Best for
1 Ben Garelick Jewelers 5.0 ★ 1,373 Engagement rings and custom design View ›
2 Colosseum Jewelry 4.9 ★ 960 Wedding bands and selling gold View ›
3 Brian Michael's Jewelers 5.0 ★ 796 Repairs, watches and gifts View ›
4 Aurum Jewelers 4.9 ★ 532 Antique, estate and custom pieces View ›
5 Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers 4.9 ★ 476 Rings and watches with mall hours View ›
5 Best Jewelry Stores in Buffalo (2026)

Jeweler profiles

BE
#1 Overall🕑 Open 5 days/wk↩ Responds to reviews

Ben Garelick Jewelers

5.01,373 Google reviews

Ben Garelick Jewelers is a jeweler at 5001 Transit Rd. Its site calls it a jewelry retailer with over 70 years of heritage, offering designer engagement rings, wedding bands and fine jewelry, and it promotes custom design, appointments and financing. Google also tags it for diamond buying, jewelry repair and watch repair.

What people praise

  • Reviewers describe staff who guided them patiently through engagement ring and wedding band designs
  • One customer had a custom anniversary piece made and was kept in the loop through the process
  • A shopper who lives an hour away calls the drive well worth it
  • A couple says staff were friendly whenever they stopped in, including to have a ring cleaned

Worth knowing

  • Google lists it as closed Sunday and Monday
Reputation scorecardrank in Buffalo
Rating5 / 5
Review volume1,373 · 98th
Confidencevery high
Recency2 months ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown99% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: A 5.0 across the largest review base on the page, and the clearest match if you want a custom or engagement ring built with a designer.

Website+1716-631-1584 Directions

5001 Transit Rd, Buffalo, NY 14221

CO
#2🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

Colosseum Jewelry

4.9960 Google reviews

Colosseum Jewelry is a jewelry store at 1 Galleria Dr in Buffalo. Google lists it as a jewelry store, jeweler, diamond buyer, gold dealer and watch store, with jewelry and watch repair. Its reviewers describe buying wedding bands and selling scrap jewelry.

What people praise

  • Reviewers describe welcoming, patient staff
  • One customer says staff were open about what they do with your jewelry and fair on scrap jewelry
  • A reviewer notes a large variety of pieces to choose from
  • Open seven days a week, per Google

Worth knowing

  • Google lists a phone number but no website, so call for details
Reputation scorecardrank in Buffalo
Rating4.9 / 5
Review volume960 · 93rd
Confidencevery high
Recency2 weeks ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown97% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: A 4.9 across more than 950 reviews. A good fit if you're buying wedding bands or want to sell old gold.

+1716-684-8384 Directions

1 Galleria Dr, Buffalo, NY 14225

Brian Michael's Jewelers logo
#3🕑 Open 6 days/wk↩ Responds to reviews

Brian Michael's Jewelers

5.0796 Google reviews

Brian Michael's Jewelers is a jewelry store at 1150 Niagara Falls Blvd in Tonawanda Town. Google tags it for jewelry repair, appraisal, design and buying, gold dealing and wedding jewelry. Reviewers describe ring sizing and repair, a watch exchange, a necklace and earrings, and a gift box for a vintage watch.

What people praise

  • Reviewers call the staff knowledgeable and low pressure
  • One customer had rings sized, fixed and cleaned in good time
  • A shopper who'd tried several local jewelers says this store had the gift box they needed
  • Several reviewers describe fair, reasonable pricing

Worth knowing

  • Google lists it as closed Sunday
Reputation scorecardrank in Buffalo
Rating5 / 5
Review volume796 · 88th
Confidencevery high
Recency5 weeks ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown97% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: A 5.0 across more than 790 reviews. Solid for repairs, watches and gift shopping as well as rings.

Website+1716-833-0700 Directions

1150 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda Town, NY 14150

Aurum Jewelers logo
#4🕑 Open 5 days/wk↩ Responds to reviews

Aurum Jewelers

4.9532 Google reviews

Aurum Jewelers is a jeweler at 487 Elmwood Ave in Buffalo. Its site says it has been creating one-of-a-kind fine jewelry for over 50 years, with custom creations, estate and antique jewelry, and repair and appraisal services. Reviewers mention colored gemstones, vintage pieces, remounting and watch maintenance.

What people praise

  • Reviewers praise the selection of vintage and antique jewelry
  • One customer says an emerald engagement ring looked newer than new after repair and repolishing
  • Another had the posts rebuilt on antique diamond earrings
  • Reviewers call the pricing fair and the service unpressured

Worth knowing

  • Google lists it as closed Sunday and Monday
Reputation scorecardrank in Buffalo
Rating4.9 / 5
Review volume532 · 83rd
Confidencehigh
Recency2 weeks ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown97% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: A 4.9 across more than 530 reviews. The best match here for restoring or remounting heirloom pieces, or for something one of a kind.

Website+1716-886-1300 Directions

487 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222

Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers logo
#5🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers

4.9476 Google reviews

Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers is a jewelry and watch store at 1 Walden Galleria in Buffalo. Its website is Rogers & Hollands, which lists engagement rings, a custom design team, financing, warranties and trade-in. Reviewers describe buying wedding rings and Hamilton watches.

What people praise

  • Reviewers call the staff helpful, friendly and unhurried
  • One customer praises a salesperson's detailed knowledge of Hamilton watches
  • Shoppers who bought rings say they found what they wanted at a price they liked
  • Open evenings and Sundays, per Google
Reputation scorecardrank in Buffalo
Rating4.9 / 5
Review volume476 · 78th
Confidencehigh
Recency7 weeks ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown95% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: A 4.9 across more than 470 reviews. Convenient for rings and watches when you want mall hours.

Website+1716-706-2900 Directions

1 Walden Galleria D224, Walden Galleria, Buffalo, NY 14225

6

Your business here

Get listed on this page, in front of local customers already searching for you.

Claim this spot ›

How the scorecard works

Rating is each store’s Google star average. Review volume is how many people have rated it, set against other local jewelers. Confidence weighs the rating by that volume, so a 4.9 from hundreds of people carries more certainty than a 5.0 from a dozen. Recency reflects how recently reviews are still arriving.

What drives jewelry prices in Buffalo?

Price depends on the metal, the stones, whether a piece is stock, custom or antique, and how much labor a repair involves. No prices are published here, so ask for written quotes on custom work and repairs, and ask whether an appraisal is included.

Where to find them

These stores are spread across Buffalo, from Transit Road and Elmwood Avenue to Niagara Falls Boulevard in Tonawanda Town and the Walden Galleria area. Searching for a jeweler near me? Each listing shows hours, a phone number and directions.

Questions to ask a jeweler

  • How long will a custom design or repair take?
  • Will you give a written quote before starting work?
  • Do you include an appraisal or certificate with the piece?
  • What is your policy on resizing, returns and warranties?
  • Do you buy gold or old jewelry, and how do you value it?
  • Can I see the stone or piece in person before I commit?

Frequently asked questions

Where can I get a ring resized or repaired in Buffalo?

A Brian Michael’s reviewer had rings sized, fixed and cleaned, and an Aurum Jewelers reviewer had an emerald ring repaired and repolished. Google also tags Ben Garelick and Colosseum Jewelry for repair services. Ask for a written quote.

Which store works with antique and estate jewelry?

Aurum Jewelers. Its site lists estate and antique jewelry among its services, and reviewers praise its vintage selection and its work on heirloom pieces.

Can I sell old gold or scrap jewelry?

Google tags Ben Garelick Jewelers, Colosseum Jewelry and Brian Michael’s Jewelers as buyers, and one Colosseum reviewer describes selling scrap jewelry. Offers vary, so ask how each store values a piece before you sell.

Who offers custom engagement rings?

Ben Garelick Jewelers promotes custom design on its site, Aurum Jewelers lists custom creations, and the Rogers & Hollands site for Ashcroft & Oak mentions a custom design team. Ask each about timelines and sketches.

Where to begin

Ben Garelick Jewelers is a sensible first call for engagement rings and custom work on sheer proven volume, and Aurum Jewelers is the call for antique and heirloom pieces. Whoever you choose, get the quote and the timeline in writing.

Own one of these businesses, or want to be here?

Claim your spot on this page: Basic listing $50 or Premium $100 for the top spot, held a full year. Both include a permanent link to your site.

Get listed See pricing