Hanover Street Bakery
Hanover Street Bakery in Mayfair is a neighborhood bakery known for pies, cakes, and everyday baked goods, with a loyal customer base built over roughly a decade. It's also used as a venue for weddings and events, a detail more than one reviewer mentions alongside the food itself. The most reviewed bakery on this page by a wide margin, it clearly does a high volume of daily trade.
What people praise
- A supporter of ten years calls it the most reliable source for baked treats and cakes
- Used as an event venue for weddings, praised for the setting
- Wide range of sweet and savory options in one shop
Worth knowing
- A reviewer flagged stale koeksisters and a store that felt dark during a power outage
- Another noted a foreign object found in a naan on one visit
Our take: It ranks first here on sheer review volume, and the loyalty behind those numbers is real, but the handful of freshness complaints are worth weighing if you're ordering for something time-sensitive.
