Skip to content
Best in Hood
Menu

5 Best Jewelry Stores in Lexington (2026)

Ranked by real Google ratings and review volume · How we chose

Talise Sterling
By Talise Sterling, Goods and Shopping · ✓ Updated · 7 min read

We compared 20 jewelry stores in Lexington on Google Maps · 5 listed · How we rank

A ring or a watch is a purchase you'll look at for years, so it helps that the jewelry stores in Lexington on this page hold more than 3,300 Google reviews between them, all rated 4.9 or higher. With stars that tight, the real question is what each store does best: estate pieces and gold buying, watches, or engagement rings.

Short answer: Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers carries the largest review base, 4.9 stars from more than 1,500 Google reviews, and reviewers praise its help with watches and ring cleaning. St. John & Myers Jewelry (4.9, more than 620 reviews) is the store reviewers describe for selling gold and its site lists estate pieces, and Schiffman's Jewelers holds a 5.0 from more than 510 reviews.
Jump to a business

Lexington Jewelers, Side by Side

# Business Rating Reviews Best for
1 Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers 4.9 ★ 1,504 Watches and rings at Fayette Mall View ›
2 St. John & Myers Jewelry 4.9 ★ 627 Estate jewelry and selling gold View ›
3 Schiffman's Jewelers 5.0 ★ 511 Watch purchases and gifts View ›
4 KAY Jewelers 4.9 ★ 381 Wedding sets and jewelry repair View ›
5 REEDS 4.9 ★ 340 Engagement rings and watches View ›
5 Best Jewelry Stores in Lexington (2026)

Where to shop for rings, watches and gold

Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers logo
#1 Overall🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers

4.91,504 Google reviews

Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers is a jewelry and watch store at Fayette Mall, and its website sits under the Rogers & Hollands name. The site lists engagement rings, a custom design team, financing, warranties, trade-in, appointments and ring care and cleaning. Reviewers mention a Hamilton watch collection, ring cleaning and help checking a watch they already owned.

What people praise

  • One reviewer had a pre-owned Rolex inspected and says the watch was polished free of charge
  • A reviewer who browsed said the ring cleaning left their rings looking better than in years
  • One reviewer says a salesperson explained the options without pressure
  • One watch collector describes a manager who followed up by phone after a purchase was missing items

Worth knowing

  • Sunday hours are shorter, noon to 6 PM per Google
Reputation scorecardrank in Lexington
Rating4.9 / 5
Review volume1,504 · 98th
Confidencevery high
Recency6 weeks ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown98% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: Holds the largest review base on this page at 4.9, and the praise keeps coming back to watches and careful, unhurried help at the counter.

3401 Nicholasville Rd #212, Lexington, KY 40503

St. John & Myers Jewelry logo
#2🕑 Open 3 days/wk↩ Responds to reviews

St. John & Myers Jewelry

4.9627 Google reviews

St. John & Myers Jewelry is an estate jeweler at 198 Moore Dr that buys and sells jewelry. Its website lists antique and vintage pieces such as Art Nouveau brooches and Victorian diamond rings, and Google tags it as a jewelry buyer and jewelry repair service as well. Reviewers describe selling gold, silver or diamonds there.

What people praise

  • One reviewer says items were evaluated in front of them and the pricing was explained clearly
  • Another was in and out in under 20 minutes with an accurate gold appraisal
  • One reviewer had a worn gold ring repaired and could not find where the fix was made
  • A reviewer notes they also have jewelry for sale if you want something unique

Worth knowing

  • Google lists hours on Wednesday, Friday and Saturday only, noon to 5 PM
Reputation scorecardrank in Lexington
Rating4.9 / 5
Review volume627 · 93rd
Confidencevery high
Recency5 weeks ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown98% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: A good fit for anyone selling old gold or hunting for estate pieces, with a 4.9 that rests on more than 620 reviews.

198 Moore Dr #104, Lexington, KY 40503

Schiffman's Jewelers logo
#3🕑 Open 5 days/wk↩ Responds to reviews

Schiffman's Jewelers

5.0511 Google reviews

Schiffman's Jewelers is a jewelry store at 4040 Finn Wy, Suite 150. Reviewers describe buying earrings, a bracelet and several watches there, including Rolex, Tudor and Hamilton models, and having a vintage watch repaired.

What people praise

  • One reviewer had a bracelet gift wrapped and shipped overnight to an out-of-town address
  • A buyer who joined a list for a Rolex says the salesperson kept in touch until it arrived
  • Reviewers name salespeople who were patient and knowledgeable about watches
  • One reviewer says a vintage watch was cleaned and repaired perfectly

Worth knowing

  • Google lists no Thursday or Sunday hours, and Wednesday closes at 3 PM
Reputation scorecardrank in Lexington
Rating5 / 5
Review volume511 · 88th
Confidencehigh
Recency2 weeks ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown99% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: A 5.0 across more than 510 reviews, with much of the praise aimed at watch buying and individual salespeople.

4040 Finn Wy #150, Lexington, KY 40517

KAY Jewelers logo
#4🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

KAY Jewelers

4.9381 Google reviews

KAY Jewelers is a chain jeweler with a Lexington store at Fayette Mall. Its website lists jewelry maintenance and repair, custom and special orders, diamond upgrades, gold exchange, appraisals and financing, and Google also tags it as a watch store and jewelry engraver. Reviewers describe shopping for engagement rings and wedding bands.

What people praise

  • One reviewer says an employee let her try on many rings without making her feel like a burden
  • A bride-to-be credits one employee with helping pick out the wedding band
  • Two reviewers credit one salesperson with helping choose a wedding set and a sapphire set
  • One reviewer praises tips for reducing wear and tear on jewelry

Worth knowing

  • One reviewer left 1 star after a disagreement over matching an online watch price
Reputation scorecardrank in Lexington
Rating4.9 / 5
Review volume381 · 83rd
Confidencehigh
Recency4 weeks ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown95% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: A mainstream pick for wedding sets, with repair among the services its site lists, and a 4.9 from more than 380 reviews.

3401 Nicholasville Rd Ste c312, Lexington, KY 40503

REEDS logo
#5🕑 Open 7 days↩ Responds to reviews

REEDS

4.9340 Google reviews

REEDS is a jeweler at 3473 Nicholasville Rd that reviewers place in Fayette Mall. Google lists it as a jewelry store, diamond buyer, gold dealer and jewelry and watch repair service. Reviewers describe buying engagement rings, an anniversary ring and a Longines timepiece.

What people praise

  • One engagement-ring buyer says the salesperson walked them through the process without fluff
  • A reviewer says staff explained diamond types and the store's warranty
  • One anniversary-ring buyer says the staff worked within a tight budget when other stores didn't
  • A reviewer who bought a rare Longines thanks the salesperson for going above and beyond

Worth knowing

  • One reviewer reported a problem dropping rings off for cleaning when the store could not find their account
Reputation scorecardrank in Lexington
Rating4.9 / 5
Review volume340 · 78th
Confidencehigh
Recency8 days ago
Info completenesssite · phone · hours
Rating breakdown95% 5-star
✓ VerifiedSource: Google

Our take: Engagement rings are the clear theme, and a 4.9 on more than 330 reviews backs it up.

3473 Nicholasville Rd Spc 704, Lexington, KY 40503

6

Your business here

Get listed on this page, in front of local customers already searching for you.

Claim this spot ›

How the scorecard reads

Rating is the live Google star average. Review volume is how many customers have rated the store, set against the other jewelers here. Confidence weighs the rating by that volume, so a 4.9 from more than 1,500 people carries more weight than a 5.0 from a few dozen. Recency shows how recently customers are still leaving reviews.

What do jewelry stores charge in Lexington? (2026)

No prices are published here. What you pay depends on the metal, the stone, whether a piece is new or estate, and whether you are buying, repairing or selling. For repairs, cleaning and appraisals, ask each store for a written quote before you leave a piece.

Where these jewelers are in Lexington

Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers, KAY Jewelers and REEDS are all on Nicholasville Rd, and reviewers and their websites tie them to Fayette Mall. St. John & Myers Jewelry is at 198 Moore Dr and Schiffman’s Jewelers is at 4040 Finn Wy. Each card lists a live phone number and directions, so you can find the closest jewelry store near you.

Questions to ask a jeweler before you buy or sell

  • Is repair or sizing done in the store, or sent out, and how long does it take?
  • What warranty or trade-in terms come with a ring or watch?
  • If I’m selling gold, will you evaluate it while I wait and explain the offer?
  • Can you appraise or verify a watch that came without paperwork?
  • What are your hours, and do I need an appointment for custom work?

Frequently asked questions

Where can I sell gold jewelry in Lexington?

St. John & Myers Jewelry is the store reviewers most often describe for selling gold, silver and diamonds, saying items were evaluated in front of them. KAY Jewelers’ website lists a gold exchange, and Google tags REEDS as a gold dealer and diamond buyer. Ask each store to explain its offer before you agree.

Which Lexington jewelers do watch buyers mention?

Reviewers describe buying a Hamilton and getting a pre-owned Rolex looked over at Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers, buying Rolex, Tudor and Hamilton watches at Schiffman’s Jewelers, and a Longines at REEDS. Google also tags KAY Jewelers as a watch store.

Can I get a ring or watch repaired at a Lexington jewelry store?

One reviewer had a worn gold ring repaired at St. John & Myers Jewelry, and another had a vintage watch repaired at Schiffman’s Jewelers. KAY Jewelers’ website lists jewelry maintenance and repair, and Google tags REEDS as a jewelry and watch repair service.

Where do Lexington reviewers shop for engagement rings?

Reviewers describe engagement-ring and wedding-band shopping at REEDS and KAY Jewelers. Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers’ website lists engagement rings and a custom design team.

Picking your jeweler

Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers has the largest review base, with reviewers praising its watch help and ring cleaning, while St. John & Myers Jewelry suits anyone selling gold or buying estate pieces. Whichever store you pick, get repair, cleaning and warranty terms in writing.

Own one of these businesses, or want to be here?

Claim your spot on this page: Basic listing $50 or Premium $100 for the top spot, held a full year. Both include a permanent link to your site.