5 Best Babysitting Services in New York (2026)

Smart Sitting is a nanny and babysitting agency offering full-time nannies, part-time nannies, on-demand babysitting for emergencies, and traveling nannies for families on the move. The agency runs background checks, safety screenings, and reference checks on every caregiver before placement, and also coordinates on-site childcare for corporate events.

Family Care Options has served New York families and travelers since 2002, offering in-home and hotel babysitting, adult care, and backup care alongside pet sitting and stroller rentals. The agency positions itself specifically for visitors, with reviewers describing sitters meeting families at hotels for the duration of a trip.

Nannies by Noa is a boutique nanny and newborn care placement agency serving New York City and the Tri-State area, matching qualified caregivers with families through interviews, reference checks, and trial periods. The agency represents both career nannies and Newborn Care Specialists, and reviewers describe a multi-step matching process designed to reduce mismatches.

A Nanny Match is a New York nanny agency run by Cindy and Kristen, pairing families with nannies and family assistants through what reviewers describe as an unusually personal, detail-oriented matching process. The agency conducts reference and background checks and takes time upfront to understand each family's specific needs before presenting candidates.

Manhattan Nannies connects families with nannies and household staff across New York City, starting by learning each family's home routine and the personalities of the children before recommending candidates. The agency, run in part by Florence and Brooke, also places household staff beyond childcare.