5 Best Trophy Shops in Chicago (2026)

C&M Awards is an Oak Forest trophy shop and engraver specializing in trophies, plaques, acrylics, certificates and custom awards for youth sports leagues and events. Reviewers describe the shop producing very large orders, over 160 trophies and 15 coaches' plaques in a single order, within tight timeframes. Long-term customers describe returning year after year for annual league awards.

Chicago Award Source is a Lincoln Park engraver and trophy shop operating since 1981, offering crystal, glass, acrylic, plaques and trophies engraved in-house and shipped nationwide. Its own site says it has completed over 600,000 engravings, with 24-hour rush service available. Reviews describe fast turnaround on both individual gift engraving and larger corporate award orders.

Trophys Are Us is a Dolton trophy shop offering trophies, plaques and acrylic awards, with reviewers describing relationships with the shop spanning over 20 and even 40 years. It has built a loyal, repeat customer base largely through word of mouth and family referrals. The shop handles both custom orders and simple repairs, like fixing a damaged existing trophy.

Cristaux International is an Elk Grove Village trophy shop and design agency specializing in luxury custom crystal awards, milestone awards, service awards and corporate building replicas. It works with national organizations and sports leagues, including taking over award operations for a national soccer league. Reviews describe named designers working closely with clients on bespoke, brand-aligned pieces rather than stock designs.

Millennium Park Jewelers & Engravers is a downtown Chicago engraver combining jewelry sales with a fast, same-day engraving service for gifts like watches, rings and champagne bottles. Reviewers describe walking in with a last-minute gift and walking out with an engraved piece within an hour, sometimes faster than the shop's own posted estimate. It holds a perfect rating across every review on file.