5 Best Trophy Shops in Seattle (2026)

Trophies2Go is a Renton-based trophy and engraving shop offering an online ordering system where customers can review a design proof before an order is finalized. Reviewers describe using the shop repeatedly for annual events like March Madness pools and youth sports leagues, citing consistent quality and fast turnaround over multiple years. Beyond standard trophies, the shop also produces custom engraved items like glass hockey pucks and phenolic labels for niche needs.

Athletic Awards Co. operates out of Seattle's Queen Anne neighborhood, producing custom trophies, plaques, and corporate awards alongside embroidery, sign, and glass etching services. Reviewers describe staff taking on last-minute, oddly shaped, or highly customized projects and delivering high-quality results under tight deadlines. The shop also retrofits older trophies onto new bases, giving it a repair capability beyond just new orders.

Northwest Trophy & Awards is a fourth-generation family-owned business operating in Woodinville since 1938, offering custom trophies, medals, crystal and glass awards, plaques, and promotional products. Reviewers describe the shop taking on unusual projects other engravers turned down, including a 40-signature engraved serving tray completed on a tight deadline. Its long tenure and named staff members like Seth and Rich come up repeatedly across reviews spanning many years.

C & M Trophy Co. is a Mountlake Terrace shop specializing in trophies, engraving, and embroidery, run with a hands-on, personal approach that reviewers consistently attribute to owner Glenda by name. The shop handles both quick-turnaround jobs, like same-day electrical meter labels, and more sentimental custom work, such as memorial plaques. Its in-house digitizing and graphic design capability lets it take on projects with unusual specifications.

American Trophies & Engraving has operated in Bellevue since 1987, offering corporate awards, sports trophies, promotional products, engraved plates, name badges, and signage. Reviewers describe the owner, Tom, taking on projects other trophy shops declined, from personalized water bottles to custom crystal plaque installations on irregularly shaped pieces. Its published pricing for individual items, like crystal cubes and acrylic awards, gives customers more transparency than shops without listed prices.