5 Best Sandwich Shops in Chicago (2026)

What people praise

• The hand-carved corned beef sandwich called out repeatedly as piled absurdly high
• Reuben and pastrami both praised for real quality and generous portions
• Beef stew singled out as an unexpected comfort-food standout
• Staff described as fast, friendly, and welcoming even during a packed lunch

Worth knowing

• Pricing runs on the higher side for a deli sandwich
• Meats can arrive pre-sliced rather than carved fresh depending on the hour

What people praise

• Cuban sandwiches consistently praised, with the pressed bread called out specifically
• Vegan selection appreciated as a genuine option, not an afterthought
• Coffee called out as excellent alongside the food
• Cozy, welcoming atmosphere with attentive staff

Worth knowing

• Parking near the Congress Parkway location can be tricky
• Bread texture on takeout orders isn't always as crisp as eating in

What people praise

• Thinly shaved Italian beef with giardiniera called genuinely good by regulars
• Fun, distinctly local decor adds character to a quick stop
• Efficient, friendly staff who keep the line moving fast
• Menu variety beyond just the Italian beef, useful near a train connection

Worth knowing

• A couple of reviewers found service a bit slower than expected for a fast-food format
• First-timers should ask for hot peppers on the sandwich itself, not just on the side

What people praise

• Highest rating on this list at 4.7
• Subs consistently described as generously stuffed, not skimpy
• The Wiseguy called out specifically as a standout order
• Fresh, crusty bread praised across many reviews

Worth knowing

• Bread options can run out later in the day
• No panini press, so all subs are served cold rather than toasted

What people praise

• The Mr. G sandwich called a defining, must-try Chicago sandwich
• Staff repeatedly described as warm and knowledgeable about the menu
• Cannoli and other Italian grocery items praised alongside the sandwiches
• Online and walk-up ordering both described as smooth

Worth knowing

• Regularly gets busy, with lines out the door at peak times
• One reviewer felt a specific sandwich was lighter on meat than expected